One thing I enjoy about going to mystery movies at my local theater is that I oftentimes end up seeing movies that probably never would've crossed my mind to attend otherwise, Sometimes they are pretty good (Sisu or How to Make a Killing) and sometimes they are very bad (Christy or Heart of the Beast), but I am always happy to have tried something outside my usual purview.
I can safely say that Hershey, which follows the life of Milton Hershey (Finn Wittrock), founder of the chocolate factory and the city named for him, is a movie I would never have sought out. Even though I enjoy Wittrock and Alexandra Daddario (who plays Kitty Hershey, Milton's wife) as performers, this movie positively drips with sentimentality. In the grand tradition of the best Hallmark movies, nothing is too hard to overcome if the characters remain positive and work at it long enough.
The saccharine tone of the movie hits us early and often: from his childhood until the movie ends, there is nothing but schmaltz layered upon this film. It's almost off-putting, but it is (thankfully) a deliberate choice from director Mark Waters, for what better way to focus on a man whose life was devoted to candy than with a sweet film that touches on his life?
The movie follows the standard plot of many a biopic before it, hitting the highlights of Hershey's life, though this one perhaps glosses over his early failures in the service of speeding up the plot. Most of the cast is sidelined, with only Wittrock and Daddario given much in the way of meat. Cameos from Richard Kind and Alan Ruck add some spice, but most of the other figures from Hershey's life mostly exist in the film to either provide someone for Hershey to overcome or to doubt Hershey when he has his next great idea. No one is bad, but the film isn't asking for anything deep from the performances. Daniel David Stewart fairs the best in my opinion, but not by a substantial amount.
The biggest critique I would throw at the movie would be that it tries to cover too much lightly instead of anything deeply. It touches upon many interesting topics, but breezes through them so quickly that everything feels like a footnote. Hershey, during his caramel company days, has a rival candymaker whom he doesn't like? A couple of short scenes before the rival disappears from the movie. The decision to create the town of Hershey, Pennsylvania? Made during a car ride, announced to his Greek chorus of supporting characters who make token protest, then we are at a montage of the city being built.
To use the candy metaphor, there's just not much to chew on with this film. It's pleasant enough, and everyone gives good-to-serviceable performances, but it is just to glossy and optimistic to be interesting. The characters don't face any real challenges, so neither does the viewer. Which, again, seems to be on purpose, so maybe nothing more was wanted than a feelgood movie that will be forgotten about in a year's time, but the potential was there for so much more.
Would I recommend the movie? Probably not, but mostly because it just isn't my type of film. I think most people could watch this and be amused enough, and it isn't without merit, but this movie is the sort that a group would compromise on moreso than seek out.
6 out of 10
